Why we shouldn’t use Play Therapy to desensitize Children with severe Sound Sensitively

I remember when I was in 1st-3rd grade, doctors, therapists, and school staff would try to expose me to noise through play. I used to see an occupational therapist twice a week, who would try to make me engage in play that involved noise. She would try to get me to play games that had buttons that would make noises, rummage around in toy boxes to get things to play with, turn on fun aqua machines that had motors, and other activities that either involved me making noise or her making noise. These activities cause me physical throbbing and stabbing pain. I had an audiologist who knew that I enjoyed listening to books, and so came up with a plan that required me to gradually increase the volume of my books, on my iPad, and TV. Turning up the volume was physically painful for me, so I stopped listening to books, using my iPad, or watching TV. Staff at school would try to make me eat in the cafeteria with my friends, participate in recess, or fun related arts classes.    

This would cause my pain level to increase and end up causing me to develop a migraine. Unfortunately trying to use play or fun activities to expose children with hyperacusis symptoms to noise, is extremely common. This is likely because the adults do not think that they are causing the child physical pain or harm, and simply think that they are having an emotional reaction to the noise. Very young children often have a hard time communicating the fact that they are in physical pain and may express this by crying, or tantruming, and even the ones who are able to communicate there pain are almost always dismissed. Unfortunately using play to expose a child to noise, that is in actual physical pain can have harmful consequences both short term and long term, by causing immediate physical pain, lingering increases in pain levels and setbacks, and traumatizing the child.

   

First, regardless of whether the noise is occurring or coming from a fun activity or during a time while the child is happy, if they experience physical pain from sounds, it will still cause them the same amount of pain. I know this from personal experience, turning up the volume on my audiobooks was physically painful for me, despite how much I enjoy books. This is why some children will cry or tantrum even during play therapy, because they are still in physical pain.

   

Second, for many people with hyperacusis the pain lingers long after the noise is over, and this increased pain level causes their tolerance level to drop even further. The days after I had therapy sessions with the OT, I would have lingering migraines. I remember the OT herself saying that I was more cooperative during our Monday sessions then our Wednesday sessions, this was because the pain had built up by Wednesday causing me to be even more sensitive. Whenever I was forced to participate in a “fun” event or activity such as the cafeteria, recess, or related arts with my friends I would have horrible migraines for about a week afterward. Using play to expose children to noise, can ultimately worsen the severity or their hyperacusis.

   

If the physical harm of play therapy isn’t enough of a reason to some people, or they refuse to accept that they are actually causing any physical pain or harm at all, there is an emotional reason why they should not use play therapy as well. Using play to expose children to noises that cause them physical pain is very traumatizing. The child will start to develop associations such as “fun is painful” or “games are painful.” I know this from personal experience, by the time I was nine I actually thought and would say to my Vision Teacher that “I did not like to have fun.” This is because that word had been so frequently used by adults when exposing me to sounds that physically hurt me.

   

Given that we don’t always know whether or not a little kid is in actual physical pain from noise or not, we need to assume that they are until they can confirm that they are not, so as not to risk harming them.

Don’t judge and compare what you don’t experience

Unfortunately so often people with severe pain hyperacusis are told by their friends, family, and society that they just need to “push themselves to do things despite the pain.” I have been told this message countless times and in countless different rewordings throughout my life.

I have had school staff, relatives, and people that I barely even know tell me things like: “pain is a part of life,” “no pain no gain,” “do it despite the pain,” “lots of people are in pain,” “you need to build character and endurance.” When I was younger and still to this day, when I try to explain about why I am unable to tolerate, participate, or do things because of the physical pain it causes me people often make these comments.

I remember very clearly a staff member at my school telling me “your going to have to do these things eventually it’s just a matter of whether you do them willingly or kicking and screaming,” and “your going to just have to go to the store” I have even had people who know me very well purposely ask me questions like “do you want to go with us out to the mall?” So that when I tell them no they can then start berating me about needing to “push myself and do things despite the pain.”

Often people think that they are being helpful by saying these things, but in reality they are being extremely offensive, ableist, and showing a great lack of empathy. People need to realize that they can NOT understand what it is like to be in someone else’s body, and it really makes me angry and hurt when people say that if they were in my situation they would do blank.

Well that’s very easy for them to say because they are not in my situation. Another thing people so often do, thinking that they are being helpful is comparing me either with other people who have hyperacusis or chronic pain and saying “so and so is able to do this or that.” Everyone’s body is different, even people with the same condition have different symptoms and severity, as well as different pain thresholds.

It’s not fair to compare people with hyperacusis with each other or other spoonies, zebras, or pain warriors. All statements like this do is make the person who is already in intense physical pain feel emotionally upset or bad about themselves. The person is likely struggling to just endure their pain on a daily basis. Also it is a very quick and easy way to push people away from you, or form a bridge in your relationship with them.

Even though it seems like people may be being overly sensitive or don’t have any endurance, it’s actually the opposite. Those with severe pain hyperacusis have to endure intense pain everyday and already push themselves just to do the things that they are doing even if it doesn’t seem like much to other people.

So when people explain to you about their pain and limitations be empathetic, and caring. Remember that pain is invisible, and you never know how much pain another person is truly in. For those of you who have been on the receiving end of such comments and statements, I am truly sorry and you never deserved to have had those things said to you.

Always remind yourself that your pain and sensitivity is NOT your fault. You endure a lot more pain on a daily basis than most people do, and are warrior even if no one else realizes it!

My Advise For Dealing With Doctors, For Hyperacusis Newbies

I was only eight years old when I was formally diagnosed with hyperacusis, although I had been experiencing symptoms for about a year and a half prior. Unfortunately as hyperacusis is such a rare condition and there was so almost no research on pain hyperacusis, meant that I was often not taken seriously. There are so many things that I have had to learn on my own, about the medical side of hyperacusis that I wish I knew when I was younger, so I wanted to share some things that have helped me navigate medical disbelief and misconceptions about hyperacusis.

You Are The Expert In Your Own Body

Let me ask you something. Who do you think knows more about Native American culture, a historian who studied it or an actual Native American who grew up on a reservation? I don’t know about you, but I would listen to the actual Native American over the historian. The same is true with doctors. They might have gone to medical school and have a degree, but they do not live with hyperacusis and have never experienced it for themselves. If the medical advice or treatment that your doctor recommends is worsening your pain and hyperacusis, then listen to your body and do what you know is best for you. Remember ultimately YOU are the only one who is going to have live inside your body and deal with the pain.

Do Your Own Research

Most doctors have never even heard of hyperacusis and those who have mostly still think that it is psychosomatic, and don’t acknowledge the physical pain. One of the most important skills for anyone with hyperacusis is being able to do their own medical research. If you know what you are experiencing in your own body and your doctors refuse to take you seriously, show them the facts or the lack of them. I have been doing my own medical research since I was 11 years old. A good way to start doing medical research is to specifically search for things like “pain hyperacusis” and “hyperacusis setbacks.” Make sure that any facts or research you present to your medical professionals is from a credible source, so that they will take you more seriously. I have found that the best way to go about presenting my research to doctors is write my own research paper, tying together my own personal experience with facts, statistics, and cited medical research. Here are a few medical articles by Hyperacusis Research in medical Journals to get you started: https://www.entandaudiologynews.com/features/audiology-features/post/unravelling-the-mystery-of-hyperacusis-with-pain

https://journals.lww.com/thehearingjournal/Pages/articleviewer.aspx?year=2019&issue=10000&article=00004&type=Fulltext

Understand That There Is A Lack Of Information

Keep in mind that there is currently very little research done on pain hyperacusis. Whenever there is a lack of information about a condition it gives medical professionals the ability to be able to claim that it is psychosomatic. This puts patients in a difficult situation because they have very little information to use in their defense. Whenever your doctors gives you treatment advice on sound exposure, ask them to show you 3 peer reviewed medical studies in which this was effective for patients with PAIN hyperacusis. If they make any claims about your pain being purely psychological, ask them to show you an article in peer reviewed medical journal that clearly states that there are no physical mechanisms involved with hyperacusis. Hint they won’t be able to find any of this information, because it doesn’t exist! Remember you have the right to question your doctors recommendations or anything they claim as fact! Another thing that I have found helpful is if you are unable to find any medical information that supports what you are experiencing, then find information that can be applied to your situation through logical comparisons. For example research about how fibromyalgia was considered a psychosomatic until 2011, and about how patients with XERODERMA PIGMENTOSUM (sunlight allergy)  conditions worsened from exposure. If all else fails, remind your doctor that there are still a lot of things medical science doesn’t know yet, and that you are the one in your body not them.

Everyone’s Body Is Different

Some cancer patients get better with chemotherapy, and others don’t. Some patients with epilepsy are able to be treated with certain medications, for others they don’t work. However for these more common and better understood conditions you less often find doctors saying “even though this is making you worse, it worked for my other patient with your condition so let’s just keep doing it.” Just because a particular treatment helps some people with hyperacusis doesn’t mean that it will have the same affect on you. Everyone’s symptoms and severity is unique and there is no one size fits all approach especially for hyperacusis. Scientists have already identified 5 subtypes of hyperacusis: loudness, annoyance, fear, pain, and vestibular. Even within pain hyperacusis new research is starting to show that there may be at least different types and causes. Remind your doctor of this information when they mention about success they have had with other patients.

Dave Vance experience with Hyperacusis

“My name is David Vance, I am 36 years of age from Toronto, Canada. I developed Hyperacusis 3 years ago after receiving chemotherapy treatments for Non hodgkins Lymphoma. The hyperacusis elevated over time, and it’s been hard managing life in almost all areas. I take things day by day, and I keep trying to search for a cure. Hyperacusis has changed my life immensely. I have a different set of friends, who I have met online, I barely see family or friends anymore. No more social gatherings, concerts etc. I was in the music business for many of years, and I believe that has contributed to my sound sensitivity. The ears are very delicate, and we need to take extra special good care. I am grateful I am alive, and here to help search for a cure for Hyperacusis, and to help others who go through it as well.”

Here it’s a poem Dave wrote about his experiences living with Hyperacusis. 

“Never ending

Trying to make it better

What can I do?

Some options to take

To loud

To much noise

It’s all around me

There’s no hiding

Piercing my ears

Piercing my head

Piercing my brain

The light around me

Giving me the shakes

Searching for silence

Searching for peace

Searching for love

Searching for ease

Just want things quiet

So I can feel

To help the world

Passion inside me

Here for a reason

Tune into the energy

Follow the universe

Always a way

Covering my ears

Keeping close to my soul

Listen to the messages

I’m not a lone”

Dave’s hyperacusis story has also been featured in a newspaper in Canada called The Globe And Mail: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/article-it-feels-like-a-knife-is-being-stabbed-into-my-ears-says-sufferer-of/

Fireworks need to be banned

The Fourth of July is known all across America for being celebrated with fireworks. For me and many others living with hyperacusis, the Fourth of July is one of the most painful days of the year due to the noise. Every year since I was 9 my mom would take me to my grandma’s house on the Fourth of July, as she has an underground basement and doesn’t live near any major firework display locations. Even from underground with hearing protection the fireworks cause me pounding pain, which lingers after the fireworks are over. 

Fireworks are 150-175db, which is more than twice as loud as the OSHA guidelines for safe noise levels. Fireworks are not an essential part of life, and silent fireworks have been invented, although they are currently not being mass produced. Those with hyperacusis suffer intense physical pain from the noise of fireworks, it is literally a form of torture for us. Imagine being beaten in the head and ears and the pain lingering like an injury, that is what fireworks are like for those with hyperacusis. Fireworks are also bad for the environment as they release a lot of toxins and chemicals into the air, they also scare farm animals and wildlife. Despite all of the harmful effects to both people and nature, fireworks continue to be a major way people celebrate special occasions.

It is illegal to beat a person up or give them electric shocks for fun, well that is what people are doing unknowing to those with hyperacusis, when they set off fireworks. Although there are laws in some states that make setting off private fireworks illegal, these laws are rarely enforced especially on the Fourth of July. Given that fireworks have no real value other than being a source of entertainment, and actually physically harm some people, there needs to be a ban on fireworks that make noise. 

Doctors need to believe their patients and take them more seriously

One of the most frustrating things about having hyperacusis, in addition to the pain of course, is having doctors not believe me about my pain. Throughout my life, especially when I was younger, I have had so many doctors say that the pain I got from sounds was just an anxiety issue. I have even had doctors who told me that I wasn’t really in that much pain, and was simply being manipulative or had behavioral problems. I remember one neurologist that I saw when I was 9 who said that my hyperacusis was simply “drama.” An audiologist that I saw at age 8 who said that I was simply using my hyperacusis as an excuse, and countless therapists who said that I just needed to “change making thinking about sound and that it was my anxiety that was causing the pain.” Due to their refusal to accept my reports of being in physical pain from sounds seriously, my hyperacusis was treated like a phobia or psychosomatic condition, with sound exposure and behavioral therapy.

I remember when I was 8 being taken to see an occupational therapist twice a week at the hospital for desensitize. In the sessions she would try to have me engage in activities that made noises that caused me pain, in addition to this we had to walk through the loud parking garage and hospital to get there. Once in the room in addition to the sounds that the OT was trying to expose me to, I was often subjected to the sharp painful sounds of hearing other patients in the hallway or other rooms. These sound exposure sessions were painful for me, and did not help my hyperacusis at all. I saw an audiologist a few months later who implemented a program where I was to gradually turn up the volume on my audio books, and start to listen to music and white noise. Turning up the volume on my books was painful and so was the music and white noise. The pain would then linger even after I turned the device off, and the increased pain made all of the other sounds hurt even more. When I was 11 and stayed in a psychiatric hospital, due to attempting suicide to try to escape from the daily pain and disbelief of hyperacusis.Unfortunately these are just two examples and I have many other memories of experiences like these. When I would tell the doctors that sound exposure was making my hyperacusis worse, they did not listen and would insist that my body would eventually over time get used to the noise.

When I was 11 years old, I and had had hyperacusis with pain for about 5 years at the time, I attempted suicide due to my hopelessness and desperation from the pain, and ended up in a psychiatric hospital. They didn’t make any noise accommodations for me during my stay, and I was forced to participate in activities all day with kids who were constantly screaming and banging. I was also exposed to loud music, movies, guitars, vacuum cleaners and much more, despite alerting staff that I was in extreme pain. The two weeks there was the most painful experience of my life so far, my head felt like someone had broken the bones in my skull and my ears felt like they were on fire. I was not allowed to even go in my bedroom to lay down during the day, barely got any sleep at night due to the noise and pain, and had to where hearing protection 24/7 because I didn’t have a quiet place to go. ( The extreme pain only made me feel more suicidal.) The doctors tried to convince my parents that I was not in any physical pain and it was just a behavioral problem. I was discharged with a behavioral plan which involved taking me off of Home & Hospital instruction and  attending school, being near the refrigerator at home, and not going in my soundproof room or closet. 

As I have gotten older I started to do my own medical research, as well use social media to connect with others who have hyperacusis. I found that my experiences with doctors not taking my pain seriously, brushing it off as physiological, and insisting that just gradually expose themselves, were unfortunately not uncommon.  According to a survey by Sanford (CoRDS), “66% of participants experience daily or continuous pain from noise exposure, for 25% the pain lasts between 5 and 24 hours for 28% it lasts days.” According to a research paper published in ENT and auiology news, Volume 27, issue 6, January/February 2019, “An even more significant finding that has historically been neglected is the issue of setbacks from new noise exposures. When asked, ‘how often does the participant have a setback that makes their condition worse?’, 36% indicated at least weekly and only 25% responded with rarely or never. This setback makes the sufferer’s condition ‘moderately worse’ for 50% and ‘worse than it ever was’ for 23%. Figure 3 shows the results for the question, ‘how long does it take for the participant to recover from a setback?” Recovery takes days for 59% and weeks for 24%. Recovery is also proportional to the loudness and/or duration of the impacting noise.” According to Clincal Advancements in Managing Hyperacusis with pain, published in the Hearing Journal, volume 72, issue 10, pages 10-12, October 2019, “A clinically focused question asked: “If you have had a clinical evaluation for your hyperacusis, did the clinician ask you any question related to setbacks?” Only 29 percent reported that the topic of setbacks was covered by their clinician. These results represent critical components that need to be comprehended in clinical evaluations. A patient’s history of setbacks should be considered when determining the best treatment approach and expected outcome. Many patients will likely rank setback prevention and reduction of pain symptoms as their top priorities. For some, perceiving sounds as excessively loud may be a low priority. In summary, the new 2019 brief hyperacusis survey reinforces the primary findings of the extensive Sanford registry. Both surveys suggest that hyperacusis with pain is common among hyperacusis sufferers. Also, many sufferers experience setbacks that temporarily or permanently make their symptoms worse. Therefore, setback prevention should be a top priority of clinical treatment programs.” 

Unfortunately the issue of doctors not believing or taking their patients pain or symptoms seriously is not only a hyperacusis issue. Through my online advocacy and connecting with others in the chronic pain and rare disease community, many of them have been told by doctors that their pain was “in their head.” Up until 2011, fibromyalgia was considered to be a psychosomatic condition, and still today many patients with this condition report not being understood or taken seriously by the medical community. Often those with complex regional pain syndrome, chronic migraines, chronic fatigue syndrome, and most painful conditions are viewed as exaggerating their symptoms of having psychological issues. Many in the rare disease community report doctors not believing them about their symptoms and it often takes many years to even get a diagnosis. 

Doctors need to remember that just because pain is invisible, or a symptom goes against what they learned in medical school doesn’t mean that it is “in their patients head, or that they or making it up.” The medical community needs acknowledge patients as the experts in their own bodies, be ok with admitting that they don’t know everything, and be willing to question what they think they know when it is not in line with their patients experiences.

Works sited:

1. https://www.entandaudiologynews.com/media/14524/entjf19-pollard.pdf

2. https://journals.lww.com/thehearingjournal/Pages/articleviewer.aspx?year=2019&issue=10000&article=00004&type=Fulltext

On The Run From Power Tools

The landscapers came to my house today, for the second day in a row, so my mother and I had to leave and go to my grandmothers house again. The noise of lawn mowers, leaf blowers, weed wackers, and any type of power tool causes me intense throbbing pain on my forehead and the sides of my head. If we do not leave quickly my pain turns into a lingering migraine. I am thankful that my mother drives me away, and that my grandmother has an underground basement that I am able to go in at her house.

    Ever since elementary school, whenever there where any powers tools or construction being done on our neighborhood my mother and I would have to leave our house. Often we would go to my grandmother’s house, but sometimes if there was construction going on there too, or if for some other reason we were unable to go to her house, it created a major problem.  As I am unable to go to most public places due to the noise, or even most friends or family members’ houses, there were times when we would literally have to just sit in the car in another neighborhood all day. The times that we were unable to leave our house quickly enough, the pain from the power tools would then linger and turn into a full out migraine. When landscapers or construction was being done after I came home from school, which meant that I was already in a lot of pain, I would be unable to sleep in my closet. The pain would then become too much from both the power tools and school combined, and even if we drove away, I would often miss school the next day, as the pain would turn into a migraine.

    The landscape’s unpredictable schedule not only causes problems for me, but for my mother as well. If my mother has an appointment, and the landscapers come to our neighborhood, she often ends up missing her appointment. Also if mom was planning on running errands nearby or doing things around the house, she is unable to do so when the landscapers come, as she has to pack up my food, medicine, and drive me away. If my mom is not home and out running errands or already at an appointment, then I end up being in a lot of pain while I wait for her to come back home and drive me away. 

    Noise from landscaping and power tools is not only a big problem for me, but for many people with hyperacusis. I am lucky, as I have a mother who can drive me away and I have my grandma’s quiet underground basement that I can go to. Landscapers and construction workers should be required to notify the people in the surrounding neighborhood of their schedule, at least a week before they plan on coming. There also needs to be some sort of special quiet soundproof center in every state that the people with hyperacusis would be able to go to, to get away from loud noises, such as landscapers and construction. 

Maryland needs to continue access to a pain-free education

The COVID-19 crisis has forced school systems and colleges around the world to switch to distance learning. Distance learning has been wonderful for me, I am able to do my assignments and meet with my classes from my room/closet with volume control. I no longer experience pain during the school day from the noise, or suffer lingering migraines everyday. Prior to COVID-19, I had requested distance-learning for medical reasons as an accommodation for many years from my school, and had always been denied. “Howard county and Maryland aren’t set up for that”, people always told me.

Now that there is a global pandemic and no one is able to attend school without putting their health at risk, suddenly we are able to magically do distance-learning! COVID-19 only proves that our state does have the capability to provide students for whom the school environment exacerbates their medical conditions, with distance-learning. No student should have to put themselves in pain or exacerbate the medical condition, just to learn and be educated.

IDEA law (individuals with disabilities education act)  guarantees FAPE (free appropriate public education), allowing students to endure physical pain is NOT and should never be considered appropriate. There are many students with different types of chronic medical conditions including but not limited to: hyperacusis,  cystic fibrosis, complex regional pain syndrome, fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue syndrome, cancer, lupus, multiple sclerosis, trigeminal  neuralgia, etc. that have benefited from distance-learning. 

Unfortunately we cannot simply trust that after this pandemic that access to distance learning will continue to be available for students will benefit from it, due to disability reasons. This is something that we, as students with chronic medical conditions must work together to fight for and demand from the higher ups. We must show that we will not allow things to return to how they were before, with our needs not getting meet, now that we have proof that something better is possible. I am  petitioning the state to demand that students continue to have access to an education that meets there medical needs, after COVID-19.  If you would like to help me fight for this, or have personally benefited from distance learning medically, please sign my petition: http://chng.it/kkNZy9Kgyt

Also please email the Maryland state department of education, Karen.salmon@Maryland.gov and let them know why we need to continue to have access to distance-learning after COVID-19. You can also email me.

Hyperacusis.awareness@gmail.com

Together let’s make our voices heard (quietly of course). 

Silent sweet 16

This past Wednesday May 20th 2020, I turned 16 years old. My 16th birthday has been the best birthday that I have had in a long time, for the first time in many years my pain level was very low on my birthday. Since my 10th birthday, despite putting on a happy face, having small quiet celebrations, and getting lots of gifts, birthday were an upsetting point for me. The thing that I wanted most was to just not be in pain my birthday, and I finally got my wish (for the most part).

It’s hard for me to Believe that I am actually 16 years old now. Looking back, I thought about how ironic it is that the things that people used to tell me I was wrong about, are now the same things that people compliment me on fighting for. I think back about the little elementary and middle school girl, who was in pain and not believed, the girl who wished she had someone who understood what it felt like to get pain from sound. I realize that I am now that person, that my younger self wanted and needed.

I am so thankful to God, for bringing me this far in life, and for giving me the will power and intelligence that I need to fight for myself and others. I am so grateful, that the research is starting to come out to support what I have been saying this whole time, and to be able connect with other people with similar situations.

I am now a R.A.R.E. (rare advocates representing everyone) advocate, a member of YARR (young adult rare representatives) part of the EveryLife Foundation, and a WeGo Health advocate.

A research paper I wrote about Hyperacusis

Introduction:

Hyperacusis is a poorly understood rare auditory disorder. Until extremely recently hyperacusis was thought to be a psychosomatic condition, however, new research findings are uncovering that hyperacusis is actually an otological and neurological condition. Unfortunately, hyperacusis currently has no cure.

Currently most doctors treat hyperacusis using some combination of TRT, desensitization, cognitive-behavioral therapy, and counseling. Unfortunately, these treatments are not always affective in hyperacusis patients and in some cases have made their condition worse. Hyperacusis Research Is a nonprofit organization dedicated to ending noise induced pain. “Hyperacusis Research is committed to finding a cure for patients whose conditions have not significantly improved by current treatment options.”

Mechanisms:

Hyperacusis mechanisms are currently not well understood. Doctors and scientists do not yet a functional model of the auditory system. Currently, the suspected theoretical mechanisms for hyperacusis are as follows.

•1. Eighth auditory nerve

2. Auditory pain fiber nerve cells

3. Auditory cortex

4. Somatosensory cortex

5. Staples’ bone

6. Hair cells in cochlear

Doctors and scientists are still doing more research into the possible mechanisms of hyperacusis.

Hyperacusis setbacks:

Hyperacusis setbacks are currently a seriously overlooked aspect of hyperacusis. As mentioned in the above section the current treatment options have worsened some patient’s hyperacusis due to the exposure aspect of these therapies. Many patients also report experiencing setbacks from normal daily activities or environmental sounds.

A hyperacusis setback is when a patients pain level is elevated, and their tolerance decreased following exposure to sounds above their tolerance threshold. More research needs to be done to help doctors and patients better understand how they can prevent setbacks. Noise levels do not have to be extreme or even above average in order to produce a setback for a person with hyperacusis.

In a survey conducted “A clinically focused question asked: “If you have had a clinical evaluation for your hyperacusis, did the clinician ask you any question related to setbacks?”

Only 29 percent reported that the topic of setbacks was covered by their clinician.” In the hyperacusis, Sanford Cords study also demonstrates that setbacks are more prominent in hyperacusis patients then previously suspected, see the data below.

62% answered ‘every day’ or ‘continuously’ (see Figure 2). Of these, 75% indicated the pain was a direct result of being around a new loud noise. Most sufferers feel the pain immediately. When asked, ‘how long does the pain last?’, respondents indicated the following: 22% – five to 24 hours; 22% – several days; and 11% – several weeks or months.

When asked, ‘how often does the participant have a setback that makes their condition worse?’, 36% indicated at least weekly and only 25% responded with rarely or never. This setback makes the sufferer’s condition ‘moderately worse’ for 50% and ‘worse than it ever was’ for 23%. Figure 3 shows the results for the question, ‘how long does it take for the participant to recover from a setback?” Recovery takes days for 59% and weeks for 24%. Recovery is also proportional to the loudness and/or duration of the impacting noise.

“ These results represent critical components that need to be comprehended in clinical evaluations. A patient’s history of setbacks should be considered when determining the best treatment approach and expected outcome. Many patients will likely rank setback prevention and reduction of pain symptoms as their top priorities.”

Although many doctors are concerned that over protection will worsen patient’s hyperacusis condition, it seems that patients are more likely to suffer from setbacks due to exposure.

A New direction in Research:

Many patients with hyperacusis have to isolate themselves in quiet in environments. Many hyperacusis patients are unable to attend malls, restaurants, or other social activities. Patients with severe hyperacusis even have a hard time doing normal household activities.

Hyperacusis Research is not only researching a cure for hyperacusis, but is also looking into management options until a cure can be found. Hyperacusis Research has a section called “quiet your world.” Hyperacusis Research has several articles on: quiet products, suggested noise reduction strategies, and hearing protection.

The importance of sound avoidance and noise management is reinforced by the above section (hyperacusis setbacks). New treatments are also being invented to help hyperacusis patients. Hyperacusis Research just received a grant from the NIH to develop a hyperacusis device.

The hyperacusis device was developed by Dr. Craig Formby and Dr. David Eddins in collaboration with Bryan Pollard the President of Hyperacusis Research. The new hyperacusis device allows the patients complete control over the sound level that they hear. “For example, the sound level to dampen loud sounds will be customized to a patient’s Loudness Discomfort Levels.” A clinical trial is currently underway to evaluate the effectiveness of this device.

Dr. Herbert Silverstein has also recently invented a surgery for hyperacusis called Round and Oval Window Reinforcement Surgery. The surgery is designed to reinforce the round and oval window with skin tissue, this in turn reduces the sound vibrations in the ear, making sounds less painfully loud for patients.

A study was conducted on adult patients with severe hyperacusis to evaluate the effectiveness of this surgery. The surgery had a positive impact on many of the subject’s hyperacusis severity. “The results suggest that reinforcement of the round and oval window with temporalis fascia or tragal perichondrium may offer a significant benefit for individuals with severe hyperacusis that has not responded to traditional therapy.

ULL scores and self-report measures postoperatively demonstrate improved noise tolerance, high patient satisfaction, and enhanced quality of life.” Not everyone agrees with the direction of this new research. Not everyone in the medical community favors the procedure.

Dan Malcore, the publisher of the Hyperacusis Network, called the procedure “a Band-aid approach” and said that it did not address “the path to recovering decreased sound tolerance by re-establishing one’s tolerance to sound.”

Instead, Malcore pointed to tinnitus retraining therapy as proper protocol and treatment for hyperacusis. Almost half of the patients with hyperacusis also have tinnitus, the perception of ringing in your ears. Silverstein disagrees.

“Most new developments are met with a negative response at first,” said Silverstein. “Change is difficult, and it isn’t until there are years of proven reliance that the medical community turns around.”

The same statement can be made about the new approach in setback prevention, pain reduction, and the new hyperacusis device.

Hyperacusis and the ADA:

Due to its previous categorization as a psychosomatic condition until recently, hyperacusis was not recognized under the ADA. Bryan Pollard the president of Hyperacusis Research in collaboration with other people has worked very hard to change this. There is now a small section in the ADA called “ Disability rights aspects of ambient noise for people

with auditory disorders under the Americans withDisabilities Act,” this section mentions hyperacusis by name.

“ HYPERACUSIS AFFECTS 19 MILLION (5.9%) AMERICAN ADULTS.

Hyperacusis, discomfort from sounds that would ordinarily be acceptable to most normally hearing people, is not well understood.” The ADA also acknowledges that current treatment options are not very affective in treatment in hyperacusis. Hyperacusis treatment includes sound therapy and counseling, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy. “These treatments rarely work. Even mild hyperacusis can cause major life disruption.”

According to the ADA the definition of a disability is “defined in the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA); a disability is a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities.”

Hyperacusis Research also partnered with quiet collaboration an organization dedicated to reducing environmental noise levels. The new recognition of Hyperacusis under the ADA is a major step forward for Hyperacusis patients in receiving necessary accommodations.

“Furthermore, the ADA standard is that “no individual shall be discriminated against based on disability in the full and equal enjoyment [emphasis added] of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation.”

Some doctors have written letters for their hyperacusis patients that entitled them to receive accommodations in the workplace or in other aspects of life. Some patients with hyperacusis have also been able to win their case in court for disability and or other accommodations. Although there are noise laws and guidelines, they generally only apply to dangerous levels of noise.

Hyperacusis patients, however, experience pain from sound at levels much lower than are capable of causing hearing loss. Although hyperacusis has now been recognized under the ADA, there are currently no specific accommodations.

The hyperacusis accommodations implemented usually depends upon the person. There are also general disability accommodations that many people with hyperacusis use these include but are not limited to: grocery delivery, disability, an adapted work environment such as working from home, help doing noisy tasks, smaller adapted classes in college, etc.

Sources:

1. Auditory Pain Pathway May Protect Against Hearing Loss

2.Auditory Nociception and Pain Hyperacusis Symposium – Hyperacusis Research

3. https://asa.scitation.org/doi/pdf/10.1121/2.0000657

4. http://www.icben.org/2017/ICBEN%202017%20Papers/SubjectArea02_Fink_0206_2332.pdf

5. Unravelling the mystery of hyperacusis with pain

6. Sarasota doctor develops treatment for hyperacusis

7. Clinical Advancements for Managing Hyperacusis with Pain : The Hearing Journal

8. Minimally Invasive Surgery for the Treatment of Hyperacusis. – PubMed – NCBI

9. Hyperacusis Device- hyperacusis research